Vinyl (rotocast) is a hollow rotational-molded part — wall thickness usually 1.5–3 mm, light for its size, drop-resistant. Iron molds run about $200–$500 per set, 1–2 weeks, OEM from 50 pieces. It suits 10–20 cm characters that need a light hand feel, small-to-medium batches, and effects built through spray-painting, pad-printing, and hand touch-up. PVC injection molding makes solid or hard-structure parts from steel molds under high pressure — tight dimensional accuracy, heavier per piece. Steel molds run about $3,000–$10,000+, lead time 20–30 days, and it makes sense at 1,000+ pieces, small high-precision parts, and snap fits, bases, or joints. Resin uses single-use silicone molds — the densest detail, but heavy and brittle, with mold cost baked into the unit price, suiting 50–500 piece statue-grade pieces or structures iron molds can’t handle. So the material for collectible figures isn’t chosen by slogan — it’s chosen by four measurable inputs: character size, structural design, color pass count, and order quantity. Then you verify the call with trial-shot weighing, wall-thickness scans, standing and drop tests, and mass-production yield.
From Demeng Toy’s actual production scheduling, vinyl, PVC injection, and resin aren’t three price tiers replacing each other — they’re three different process routes. The table below compares them across material, process, detail, durability, unit price, and MOQ; prices assume regular complexity, a 15–20 cm character, and exclude freight and special packaging. Drawings and quantities decide the real number. This is the core of any vinyl vs PVC decision — and where pvc vs resin stops being a price question and becomes a structure question.
| Dimension | Rotocast Vinyl | PVC Injection Molding | Resin Casting |
|---|---|---|---|
| Material | PVC paste resin, stabilizers, color pastes | PVC / ABS and other thermoplastics | Polyurethane (PU) resin primarily |
| Molding process | Paste poured into iron mold, two-axis rotation in vinyl oven, hollow wall-coating | Molten plastic injected into steel mold under high pressure, cooled and demolded, solid or hard structure | Resin poured into silicone mold, cured at room temperature or heated, hand-cast |
| Typical wall/structure | Hollow, wall ~1.5–3 mm, thin head + thick feet to lower CoG | Solid or ribbed, tight tolerances, snaps/joints/bases possible | Solid, densest detail, thin walls and sharp points render well, but brittle |
| Detail level | Medium — limited by rotational molding; fine tips and micro-texture below injection/resin | High — mold precision suits small fine structures and hard edges | Highest — silicone copies extreme micro-texture, statue-grade detail |
| Durability | Light, drop-resistant, softer feel; surface scratches easily, gates hand-trimmed | Hard, durable, dimensionally stable; heavier, corners can chip on drops | Heavy, brittle, snaps on impact — display, not daily handling |
| Mold type & cost | Iron mold, ~$200–$500/set, 1–2 weeks; rusts if poorly maintained | Steel mold, ~$3,000–$10,000+/set, 20–30 days; long life | Silicone mold, essentially single-use; mold fee amortized into unit price |
| MOQ (Demeng standard) | OEM from 50 pcs | Economical at 1,000+; small runs can’t amortize tooling | Suits 50–500 pcs, extreme small-batch high detail |
| Reference unit price | 100–500 pcs ~$15–28; 1,000+ ~$8–15 | 500 pcs ~$12–22; 1,000+ ~$8–16 | 500 pcs ~$25–40; 100–500 pcs often $30–50+, incl. mold amortization |
| Painting | Spray + pad-print + hand touch-up; overspray covered by craftsmen | Spray + pad-print; hard surface holds paint well, good for many passes | Hand-paint/airbrush dominant; dense detail, high labor share |
| Reorder capability | Molds reusable; reorders pay production + packaging only | Steel molds long-lived, stable reorders | Silicone molds single-use; reorders require recasting |
| Main risks | Uneven walls, bubbles, soft gate collapse, mold rust | Expensive tooling, sink marks, weld lines, uneconomical small runs | Bubbles, brittle fracture, short silicone mold life, high unit price |
| Best for | Blind boxes, pops, designer toys, small-medium batches, light feel + drop resistance | High volume, small high-precision parts, snaps/bases/joints, hard structures | High-detail statues, tiny batches, structures iron molds can’t do |
| Demeng’s advice | Core route, 12 years of experience, runs from 50 pcs | Taken by project; steel molds pay off at 1,000+ | By project, for 50–500 pc high-detail pieces; quotes include mold amortization |
| Hybrid options | Vinyl body + injection base/snaps/transparent parts — light feel plus structural strength | Same, split by component | Resin body + vinyl accessories — rare but doable |
One-line selection rule: look at character size, structural design, color pass count, and order quantity — not unit price alone. 10–20 cm, light feel, 50–1,000 pieces: vinyl is the safest. Small, high-precision, snaps and joints, 1,000+: injection fits better. 50–500 pieces, dense detail, statue-leaning: resin is worth it.
Vinyl, put simply, is rotational molding making hollow parts. PVC paste resin, stabilizers, and color pastes are blended into a slurry, poured into an iron mold, which is closed and loaded into the vinyl oven. The mold rotates on two axes, coating the cavity wall layer by layer; after cooling and demolding you have a hollow white blank — then trimming, sanding, spray-painting, pad-printing, and assembly turn it into a figure you can hold. Vinyl pieces are light, drop-resistant, and softer in the hand. Wall thickness generally runs 1.5–3 mm, and thin-head-thick-feet balances the center of gravity. It suits blind boxes, pops, and designer toys — 10–20 cm characters in small-to-medium batches. It’s not the same game as injection: rotocast vs injection is a trade — vinyl wins on cheap tooling, reorders, and a hollow light feel; injection wins on precision and ultra-high volume. The two are combined according to the character’s structure.
From Demeng Toy’s seat, PVC injection is a different route: thermoplastics like PVC or ABS are heated to melt, forced into a steel mold under high pressure, cooled and demolded — out comes a solid or ribbed hard part, not vinyl’s hollow thin wall. Its strengths are dimensional accuracy and structural rigidity: snap fits, bases, joints, and transparent parts that vinyl struggles with are exactly where rotocast vs injection tips toward injection; its gates are hard and handled with shears and machining. The cost sits in the tooling — steel molds generally run $3,000–$10,000+ with 20–30 day lead times, so small runs can’t amortize them. Demeng Toy usually recommends going steel at 1,000+ pieces; around 500 pieces the unit price is roughly $12–$22, and at 1,000+ it reaches $8–$16.
Resin walks the silicone-mold casting road — a different world from vinyl’s iron molds. Silicone molds are essentially single-use: recast after one batch and they’re spent, so resin quotes bake the mold fee into the unit price. The price looks high, but it’s one-time tooling amortized in. Its strength is detail: silicone copies extreme micro-texture, thin walls, and sharp points, suiting statue-grade pieces — collector displays, prototype showpieces, structures iron molds can’t do. The costs are equally clear: resin parts are heavy and brittle, snapping on impact; they’re for display, not for players handling them daily; and reorders require recasting, unlike reusable iron molds. So Demeng Toy generally recommends resin only for 50–500 piece runs with dense detail and a statue feel — at higher volumes it stops paying. Collectors often ask sofubi vs vinyl: sofubi is the Japanese soft-vinyl tradition — essentially the same rotocast vinyl process, but tuned for a softer, springier hand feel and retro kaiju character. If you want that sofubi feel, you’re still on the vinyl line, just with adjusted paste formulation and wall design.
Don’t open by asking “which is best.” Ask yourself four questions first: how big is the character, how complex is the structure, how many color passes, and how many pieces do you plan to make. Demeng Toy routes you by those four answers — we never push the expensive option. 10–20 cm, light feel, drop and handle safe, blind box or pop: go vinyl. This is our core line — rotational hollow molding, 1.5–3 mm walls, thin-head-thick-feet for balance, iron molds at $200–$500 per set in 1–2 weeks, OEM from 50 pieces, and runs from 50 to 1,000 all work. Overspray gets hand-fixed; eyes and logos go pad-print or waterslide; molds stay ready for reorders. Small size, high precision, snaps/joints/bases — or 1,000+ pieces: consider PVC injection. Steel molds at $3,000–$10,000+, 20–30 day lead time; small runs can’t amortize. But the precision and rigidity handle hard edges and moving parts vinyl can’t. We take it by project and often mix it with vinyl — body rotocast, base and snaps injected. 50–500 pieces, extreme detail, statue display, structures iron molds can’t do: that’s when resin earns its place. Silicone molds are essentially single-use, tooling amortizes into the unit price, hence the high sticker; parts are heavy and brittle — for looking, not daily handling; and reorders mean recasting.
The right material for collectible figures comes down to four measurable things — size, structure, color passes, quantity — then trial-shot weighing, wall-thickness scans, standing and drop tests, and production yield to prove the call. Vinyl vs PVC vs resin isn’t a ranking; it’s a routing decision.
Demeng Toy is a Shenzhen factory that has made custom vinyl figures for 12 years, with 2,000+ brands behind us. Vinyl is the main business; injection and resin run by project, and droplet epoxy we basically don’t touch. We do not push premium processes blindly. We match the right process based on figure size, structural design, color pass count and order quantity, and validate every decision with trial-shot weighing, wall-thickness scans, drop tests and mass-production yield checks.